Comments on: Webdynpro for Java or Webdynpro for ABAP? http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/ Accessing SAP in this brave new open world Wed, 21 Apr 2010 06:58:02 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.9.2 hourly 1 By: SapJerk http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-7183 SapJerk Mon, 29 Mar 2010 06:58:25 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-7183 Systems Applications and Products. Java comes in Applications phase , soon after the Application gets successful,Products will Take control. ABAP is in between Application and Product, Its half a product,half a language with a lot of limitations. java on the other side has not limitations, you can virutally do anything you like, can keep changing to the Technology.In an ABAP world ,one should wait for the new enhancements to be released by SAP,but in a java world there is no tomorrow which you can do it today.Its a question of Go or No Go in a Running Race. Systems Applications and Products. Java comes in Applications phase , soon after the Application gets successful,Products will Take control. ABAP is in between Application and Product, Its half a product,half a language with a lot of limitations. java on the other side has not limitations, you can virutally do anything you like, can keep changing to the Technology.In an ABAP world ,one should wait for the new enhancements to be released by SAP,but in a java world there is no tomorrow which you can do it today.Its a question of Go or No Go in a Running Race.

]]> By: Swapnil http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6997 Swapnil Thu, 15 Oct 2009 06:16:52 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6997 Hello, In latest presentations about EHP4 and ESS/MSS, I came to know that SAP will prefer WDA for writing business applications. Especially with FPM for WDA this seems catching up very fast. If ESS/MSS is re-written in WDA (Labs are too fast at this!), will the WDJ still be having same importance or preference? Also if we take typical implementaion scenario - we always have a abap pool developing custom applications using abap workbench, will there be a chance of seeing such java pool developing custom applications using NWDI/CE? I have seen NWDI as a pain point in many implementations (not even it is costly the installation and configuration also requires considerable time and effort), is there any chance SAP will ship it free with CE similar to ABAP workbench? I dont know if this is right place to put these questions but i found the discussion here very interesting and i think experts in ui area have contributed here...hoping to see a reply. :-) Hello,

In latest presentations about EHP4 and ESS/MSS, I came to know that SAP will prefer WDA for writing business applications. Especially with FPM for WDA this seems catching up very fast. If ESS/MSS is re-written in WDA (Labs are too fast at this!), will the WDJ still be having same importance or preference?
Also if we take typical implementaion scenario – we always have a abap pool developing custom applications using abap workbench, will there be a chance of seeing such java pool developing custom applications using NWDI/CE?
I have seen NWDI as a pain point in many implementations (not even it is costly the installation and configuration also requires considerable time and effort), is there any chance SAP will ship it free with CE similar to ABAP workbench?
I dont know if this is right place to put these questions but i found the discussion here very interesting and i think experts in ui area have contributed here…hoping to see a reply. :-)

]]> By: Zsolt http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6904 Zsolt Tue, 22 Sep 2009 16:40:29 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6904 I do web dynpro for abap development, so I am a bit biased. Earlier - 2007 - we had some problems with it, but now the system got faster and more stable and thus development easier. Web Dynpro for Abap is fully integrated into the SAP development system (transport, activation, ...), so you can deliver in about 50% of the time compared to external - even Web Dynpro for Java - solutions. That decides the question, doesn't it? I do web dynpro for abap development, so I am a bit biased.
Earlier – 2007 – we had some problems with it, but now the system got faster and more stable and thus development easier.
Web Dynpro for Abap is fully integrated into the SAP development system (transport, activation, …), so you can deliver in about 50% of the time compared to external – even Web Dynpro for Java – solutions. That decides the question, doesn’t it?

]]> By: ITSIACDCOMBCBSPWDJWDA http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6865 ITSIACDCOMBCBSPWDJWDA Wed, 29 Jul 2009 00:21:24 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6865 What ever happened to ITS, IAC, DCOM, Business Connector, BSP? They all have gone with ever changing SAP's direction in application design technology and technical landscape changes. Only things is we've spent years learning these then all of sudden it's obsolete. Would WDJ face the same fate with the introduction of WDA? It's certainly a possiblility so therees doubts about spending time and money learning WDJ. If we can do the full J2EE like the CRM ECommerce then why WDJ? With WDJ's limitations of using the RFC ABAP in the backend and NWDI requirements, WDA will soon over come WDJ. If there's application requirement for web enabled application then I would suggest full J2EE/MVC2 CRM or R/3 ECommerce or .net. For thin client, intranet development, I would suggest WDA. Hope this help. What ever happened to ITS, IAC, DCOM, Business Connector, BSP? They all have gone with ever changing SAP’s direction in application design technology and technical landscape changes. Only things is we’ve spent years learning these then all of sudden it’s obsolete. Would WDJ face the same fate with the introduction of WDA? It’s certainly a possiblility so therees doubts about spending time and money learning WDJ.

If we can do the full J2EE like the CRM ECommerce then why WDJ? With WDJ’s limitations of using the RFC ABAP in the backend and NWDI requirements, WDA will soon over come WDJ. If there’s application requirement for web enabled application then I would suggest full J2EE/MVC2 CRM or R/3 ECommerce or .net.

For thin client, intranet development, I would suggest WDA.

Hope this help.

]]> By: Philip http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6742 Philip Sun, 01 Mar 2009 21:47:46 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6742 Hi I am working in java and J2ee for last 10 years, I would like to move to Java Web Dynpro. Since I am not having any experience with SAP, hwo easy it will to find a job in Java Web Dynpro as Fresh starter. Please give some idea Regards Philip Hi
I am working in java and J2ee for last 10 years, I would like to move to Java Web Dynpro. Since I am not having any experience with SAP, hwo easy it will to find a job in Java Web Dynpro as Fresh starter.
Please give some idea
Regards
Philip

]]> By: awd http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6667 awd Mon, 05 Jan 2009 11:25:05 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6667 yse you could run java script via iframe component in abap web dynpro yse you could run java script via iframe component in abap web dynpro

]]> By: Sreekanth http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6612 Sreekanth Thu, 13 Nov 2008 05:54:01 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6612 Hi, goog article. Found a blog which gives some more point on the same topic. http://www.sapnxt.co.nr/2008/11/difference-between-webdynpro-abap-and.html Hi, goog article.
Found a blog which gives some more point on the same topic.
http://www.sapnxt.co.nr/2008/11/difference-between-webdynpro-abap-and.html

]]> By: Mogens Enevoldsen http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6600 Mogens Enevoldsen Mon, 03 Nov 2008 21:42:25 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6600 Hi rj, If you want to build HTML user-interfaces which uses JavaScript then you should look at SAP BSP instead. In Webdynpro you cannot use JavaScripts because it should be possible to render the UI to other clients than 'just' a browser. E.g - with NetWeaver 7.1 you can render your webdynpro application unchanged to RIA client like SAP Business client - which uses Adobe Flex as a presentation layer... br, Mogens (www.dev-trend.com) Hi rj,
If you want to build HTML user-interfaces which uses JavaScript then you should look at SAP BSP instead. In Webdynpro you cannot use JavaScripts because it should be possible to render the UI to other clients than ‘just’ a browser. E.g – with NetWeaver 7.1 you can render your webdynpro application unchanged to RIA client like SAP Business client – which uses Adobe Flex as a presentation layer…

br,
Mogens (www.dev-trend.com)

]]> By: shanon http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6324 shanon Fri, 26 Sep 2008 06:21:29 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6324 Hi Friendz I have an interst to learn the SAPFrontend designing. I know that there r two technologies to desing the screens.i.e Webdynpro for java nad abap.In these two technologies which is the best to learn and which one have the more craze in job wise. Hi Friendz

I have an interst to learn the SAPFrontend designing. I know that there r two technologies to desing the screens.i.e Webdynpro for java nad abap.In these two technologies which is the best to learn and which one have the more craze in job wise.

]]> By: andres http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/comment-page-1/#comment-6184 andres Thu, 14 Aug 2008 17:30:20 +0000 http://www.sapfrontend.com/webdynpro-for-java-or-webdynpro-for-abap/#comment-6184 I am a developer and desing iviews between abap and java i developer in java webdynpro and make de rfc in abap and is not very dificult. Only just as we're eager and you can achieve good results. I am a developer and desing iviews between abap and java i developer in java webdynpro and make de rfc in abap and is not very dificult. Only just as we’re eager and you can achieve good results.

]]>